• Blog Home
  • Comics
  • Videos
  • Downloads
  • Resources
  • About
  • Contact
Bill's English
Follow me

We Don't Drink the Soup--We Eat It!

9/16/2013

2 Comments

 
My students had to identify the main verbs in a paragraph and mistakenly marked a few infinitives like the following:

Chop the carrots into small pieces to make them cook faster.

So I explained that the infinitive bolded above is working more like an adverb. Compare the above sentence to the following:

Chop the carrots in small pieces quickly/efficiently/whimsically.

Infinitive verb phrases like these provide a reason for the main verb (chop), and thus, it is not the main verb of the sentence. 

Person A: "Why did you chop the carrots into small pieces?"
Person B: "To make them cook faster."

I then wrote the following sentence on the board as an example:

She ate the soup to make him happy. 

This example looks a bit contrived, but it really happened. I made some soup last weekend that turned out pretty bad, so I couldn't help but tell my class this story about my wife's polite endurance and my two-year-old son's brutal honesty: 

"UGH! OH YUCK!" "Charlie! We don't say 'yuck' with food. It's very rude." "Daddy, this soup is not very good." (Honestly, it was real bad)

— Bill Blond (@BillsEnglish) September 11, 2013
Anyway, so then I went on to explain the grammar: 

Me: "See, this part, 'to make him happy,' is the reason. You could ask, 'Why did she eat the soup?' and the answer would be, 'to make him happy.'"

Student: "Eat it?"

Other Student: "No, drink it."

Student: "Drink the soup!"

Me: "I'm sorry, what?"

Other student: "It should be drink!"

Me: "Oh, okay, I see. Yes, in many languages you drink soup. I know that in Japanese, Chinese, Korean, and Arabic, you drink soup,  but in English, you eat it."

Students: "Whaaaat?! Why?!"

Luckily, I found out from a German-speaking colleague that Germans eat their soup as well, so I knew there was some safety in numbers and I was able to cite that as another example:

Me: "I don't know, but in English and in German, most of our soups have pieces in it that you have to chew. Anyway, you can say 'drink soup,' and people will get what you mean, but it will just sound weird."

Student: "I think you should change your way." (if more languages say drink, then English should do that, too).

I'm not so familiar with Middle-Eastern soups, but I know the soups I encountered in Korea and Japan were mostly liquid, and they were quite drinkable. Most American soups, on the other hand, are not. Of course this is all anecdotal and based on my own limited culinary knowledge, but I think the soups of European descent (if there were such a thing--we'll need genetic testing to be sure) seem to be chunkier in nature. Even drinkable soups like tomato soup are often accompanied with a grilled cheese sandwich, an instantiation of the Soup and Sandwich Phenomenon (on a side note, while I was conducting grilled cheese research, I discovered "the cheese dream." Thank you, Wikipedia for documenting this gem of an Americanism). 

I don't know why, but these kinds of interactions intrigue me every time. The shock and surprise in my students' voices when they hear something strange about English--their reaction, it's always new, always sudden, that I feel like I get to learn it all again along with them. It never gets old.

How about you? Are there any things you teach that always seem to surprise your students? Do you get a kick out of seeing them discovering the weirdness of English?

-Bill
2 Comments
Diane Nicholls
9/16/2013 09:39:49 pm

Another nice thought-provoking post, Bill. Thanks! I searched a corpus for verb collocates with 'soup' and found the intriguing contradiction in the fact that we definitely 'eat' soup, and yet, we also 'slurp' and 'sip' soup, as we would, say, tea or coffee. Fascinating weirdness everywhere :-)

Reply
Bill link
9/30/2013 04:17:30 pm

Thank you for the comment and corpus information!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Hi! I'm Bill.

    Picture
    I'm all about making English more accessible to English language learners and their teachers. Click here to learn more about me and my site.
    View my profile on LinkedIn
    Blog Home
    Comics
    Videos
    Downloads
    Resources
    About
    Contact

    Latest Comic:

    Archives

    May 2019
    September 2018
    July 2018
    December 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    February 2013

    Categories

    All
    Action Vs. Non Action Verbs
    Action Vs. Non-action Verbs
    Adjectival Nouns
    Adverbial Phrases
    Americans
    Assessment
    Auxiliary Verbs
    Cartoon
    Citation
    Clauses
    Collocations
    Comics
    Communicative Language Teaching
    Complete Sentences
    Complex Sentences
    Composition
    Contest
    Corpus
    Count Vs. Noncount
    Credibility
    Critical Thinking
    Cross-linguistic Interference
    Culture
    Descriptivism Vs. Prescriptivism
    Dialect
    Extensive Reading
    Form-focused Instruction
    Fragments
    Grading
    Grammar
    Helping Verbs
    Homophones
    Idiom
    Incomplete Sentences
    Infinitives
    -ing Vs -ed
    Intensive Reading
    Japanese
    Listening
    Modals
    Nominalization
    Non Restrictive Relative Clauses
    Non-restrictive Relative Clauses
    Noun Phrases
    Part Of Speech
    Passive Vs Active Voice
    Pedagogy
    Phrasal Verbs
    Plagiarism
    Present Perfect
    Pronunciation
    Relative Clauses
    Research
    Restrictive Relative Clauses
    Rhetoric
    Shell Nouns
    Simple Past
    Simple Sentences
    Sla
    Speaking
    Spelling
    Stative Vs. Dynamic Verbs
    Stress
    Stress Timed
    Stress-timed
    Stress Timed Language
    Stress-timed Language
    Syllable-timed
    Take It Literally
    Teacher Problems
    Tense
    Transformation
    Verbalization
    Vocabulary
    Vowel Reduction
    Vowels
    Which Vs. That
    Word Forms
    Working With Sources
    #writingtips

    RSS Feed

    Privacy Policy

    Click here to read my privacy policy.
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.